Thursday, March 3, 2016

The Steve and Rick Show

Forget John Galt!
Who is Dr. Steven Scott?
It's a name Gov. Rick Scott* 
doesn't want you to know
*no relation other than  fiduciary


Where to, lady?


         Jane just had a heart attack while shopping at the Broward Mall.
          Now the nice paramedic is asking Jane which hospital Emergency Room she would like to visit for life-saving care.
          "America has the finest free market health care system in the world," the paramedic tells Jane. "And part of the beauty is people with  serious cardiac issues like you have a free choice regarding the emergency care vendor."

          "Gosh," Jane gasps between breaths from her oxygen mask, "is this a great couuntry, or what?"
          "No, Mam," the paramedic laughs. "None of that socialized-commie health care for us!"   

          Naturally, like most wise health care consumers, Jane is looking for the best bang for her heart attack buck.
          Which is how and why Florida's Agency for Health Care Administration operates an easy to access internet site with all the information any  penny-wise heart attack victim will need.
     
                Congestive Heart Failure
                                 Average Charge  
             Public                       2007           2014 
             Broward Health         $79,413      $83,645.                                     Coral Springs            $48,689      $39,753
             Imperial Point            $38,543      $31,657
             North Broward           $47,777      $48,920
             Memorial Miramar      $41,055      $72,911
             Memorial Pembroke   $49,309      $73,848
             Memorial Regional     $62,971      $109,703
             Memorial South         $46,512       $51,559
             Memorial West           $44,279      $87,678             

             Private
             Cleveland Clinic         $47,071      $52,442
             Florida Medical          $85,872      $103,908
             Holy Cross                 $75,438      $65,475

             Northwest                  $52,125      $105,247
             Plantation                  $61,733      $120,293
             University                   $46,970      $73,869
             Westside                    $68,667      $101,638

             
                  

Wednesday, March 2, 2016

More Anomalies...

   Data and anecdotal material suggest more health care consumers are relying on Emergency Rooms versus private physicians for their health care needs.
   Further, a comparison of Broward's two tax suppported hospital systems suggests the North Broward Hospital District is using tax dollars to compensate for its low patient charges and reimbursement levels -- and thus engaging in unfair competition with private hospitals in its market area.
   Which is good news for a savvy health care consumer.
   But maybe bad news for consumers forced to seek care from hospitals other than those operated by Broward Health. 

Broward Health                          2008             2014
  tax suppported
Broward Medical
Adjusted Admissions               41,332       44,077
Charge per Adj. Admission    $39,204      $39,900 
ER Visits                                 75,499        91,025
Charge per ER Visit               $2,468       $2,982
Coral Springs
Adjusted Admissions               21,397        25,309
Charge per Adj. Admission     $26,129      $25,258            
ER Visits                                 36,153        53,395
Charge per ER Visit               $3,296        $3,583
Imperial Point
Adjusted Admissions                14,690       17,954
Charge per Adj. Admission      $24,023     $23,635
ER Visits                                  18,391        25,797
Charge per ER Visit                $2,281       $2,979
North Broward 
Adjusted Admissions                 21,575       21,000
Charge per Adj. Admission      $36,216      $45,525
ER Visits                                    38,848       43,451
Charge per ER Visit                  $2,488        $3,521

Memorial Healthcare                 2008                2014
tax supported                                                                                    
Memorial Miramar
Adjusted Admissions                18,121          18,509
Charge per Adj. Admission      $23,541        $41,502            

ER Visits                                   23,573          27,985
Charge per ER Visit                 $2,784          $4,815  

Memorial Pembroke
Adjusted Admissions                 14,636          12,560
Charge per Adj. Admission       $31,346        $55,842          

ER Visits                                    23,105          26,365
Charge per ER Visit                  $2,304          $5,237  
Memorial Regional
Adjusted Admissions                 66,415           61,838

Charge per Adj. Admission      $35,766         $63,507       
ER Visits                                   85,102           102,385
Charge per ER Visit                 $2,069           $3,914   
Memorial West
Adjusted Admissions                 40,207           40,505
Charge per Adj. Admission      $28,453         $54,973          
ER Visits                                   39,850           50,162
Charge per ER Visit                 $2,344           $4,969   

Private Hospitals                            2008                  
2014
Cleveland Clinic 
non profit
 Adjusted Admissions                  18,048         19,282
Charge per Adj. Admission         $33,540      $51,317           

ER Visits                                     15,445          21,059
Charge per ER Visit                   $2,203        $5,550        
Holy Cross non profit
Adjusted Admissions                   29,696         30,124
Charge per Adj. Admission         $49,797      $47,079        
ER Visits                                      26,710         39,168
Charge per ER Visit                    $2,520         $4,104       
Northwest   for profit
Adjusted Admissions                   17,950          21,095
Charge per Adj. Admission         $39,110       $69,049         
ER Visits                                      23,381         35,819
Charge per ER Visit                    $3,301         $6,864   
Plantation   for profit
Adjusted Admissions                   13,387           41,866*
Charge per Adj. Admission         $41,623         $63,389   
ER Visits                                      30,582          51,882*
Charge per ER Visit                     $3,334          $5,827 
University   for profit
Adjusted Admissions                    14,129          17,435
Charge per Adj. Admission          $32,251       $49,166      
ER Visits                                       17,594         26,456
Charge per ER Visit                     $4,056         $7,370
Westside   for profit
Adjusted Admissions                    16,906         18,744
Charge per Adj. Admission          $45,907       $71,005        
ER Visits                                       24,679         32,479
Charge per ER Visit                     $3,037         $7,370 
     
*Plantation data combined with Mercy in Miami-Dade County  Adjusted Admission - Standard Health Care industry baseline based on a formula that enables the comparison of one hospital or hospital group to another.       

Tuesday, March 1, 2016

"A sharp decline"...?

    Moody's Investor Service, Inc. has downgraded the bonds issued by Broward Health, citing a "sharp decline" in financial performance, no clear plan for improvements, turnover in senior management and the presence of outside investigations.
     The rating of the North Broward Hospital Disrrict, the organization's legal name,was downgraded from A2 to Baa2, a change that Moody's said reflects deficit operations and "extremely thin cash flow" occurring "without a clear plan for regaining operational balance." 
                                South Florida Sun-Sentinel  -3/1/2016  
        North Broward Hospital District
                 Broward Health
      (All figures per adjusted admission)
Fiscal Year             2015         2016
                      (First Seven Months)
Gross Charges             $33,090        $33,385            0.9%
Deductions                   ($25,200)    ($25,800)      

Bad Debt                       ($3,366)      ($3,742)
   Charity Care            ($1,411)        ($1,355) 
   3rd Party,Other       ($20,423)    ($20,703)
Total Reimbursed        $8,529          $8,169            (4.2%)
Per $1 gross charge    23.8 cents    22.7 cents       (4.6%)
Other Op. Revenue      $424            $512              20.7%  
Net Operating Rev.     $8,952           $8,678            (3.1%)    
Non Operating Rev.    $1,313            $850              (35.3%)  
Total Revenue               $10,265        $9,528            (7.2%)
Operating Exp.           ($9,143)        ($9,709
)  
Non Op. Expenses       ($216)           ($207)
Total Expenses*             ($9,359)       ($9,916)            5.9% 
Surplus (Loss)*            $906         ($388)        (131%) ???
                                                    *Excluding Depreciation
            Source - Broward Health - 2/18/2016
              Where's the Grand Jury?

Thursday, February 25, 2016

Accountability - NOT!


                 In the Beginning...
     Today's North Broward Hospital District (dba Broward Health) was created by an act of the Florida legislature to meet the then major health care needs of some 100,000 all-white, non-Jewish residents living north of today's Dania "cut off" canal in the mid-1950's.
        Governance was provided by a seven-member Board of Commissioners appointed by the Governor of Florida.
        With less than 50 beds, the original Broward General Hospital provided life-saving care to an all-white patient population suffering from the likes of appendicitis, pneumonia, badly broken bones, gun shot wounds and other grave injuries.

        While organ transplants and open heart surgery were the stuff of science fiction.    
         But then Broward 60-plus years ago was part of the segregated South where Fort Lauderdale police  routinely questioned any "colored boy" found east of the Flagler Railroad tracks after dark...
        And where:

        - Broward's population lived well east of today's Route 441...
       - Most tourists arrived by train, car and a few prop-driven aircraft to stay in one of two hotels, or a handful of mom-and-pop motels....    
       -  And local government was run by all-White Good Old Boys called "Dixiecrats." 

        I know all this having spent much of my boyhood in Broward where everything from drinking fountains, to schools, restaurants, buses, grocery stores, and neighborhoods was sharply divided between "Colored" and "White".
       That was then.

       And a world away. 
       Today, as the nation's ninth largest public health care system, the North Broward Hospital District still remains under the jurisdiction of seven Commissioners politically appointed by the Governor of Florida.
        Thus, today's District's  Commissioners serve as "available" Republicans - despite their total ignorance of institutionalized urban health care in the 21st century.
         Which explains the gaggle of lobbyists, stock brokers, lawyers and retired politicians governing a $1.2 billion tax-supported system of urban hospitals and clinics serving an urban  population of nearly a million multi racial and ethnic residents.
         Which boggles. 

         So much for the back story...
                    The Sound of Silence 
     Each regular monthly meeting of the District's seven-member governing Board begins with an opportunity for visitors to address the Commissioners.
      However, by tradition -- but not policy -- the politically-appointed Commissioners routinely (and selectively) decline to respond to questions from District taxpayers.
      For example, yesterday (2/24/16), as a District taxpayer, I was met with a wall of silence from the  Commissioners after seeking an explanation for  the giant health care system's current (and mysterious) financial meltdown.
      Like...

      A comparison of the first seven months of Fiscal Year 2015 versus Fiscal Year  2016 reveals a stunning $91 million negative "swing" in the District's bottom surplus revenue.
                 North Broward Hospital District

             First Seven Months of Fiscal Year
                     (Per adjusted admission*)

                                  FY 2015       FY 2016
Adjusted admissions  69,441              68,754

Gross Charges              $34,403           $33,385       (2.9%)
 Deductions                  $25,201            $25,800       2.4%
 Reimbursement          $8,529              $8,168         (4,2%)
 Total Revenue             $10,265            $9,528         (7.2%)
 Total Expenses          ($9,765)          ($10,331)        5.8%
 Surplus (Loss)             $500               ($803)           (261%)       
*Adjusted admission - Standard healthcare industry baseline 
                               According to Plan?
        The Broward Health's fiscal year runs from July through June of the following year.
        However, due to a long-standing anomaly, Commissioners are asked to approve the District budget three months into their current fiscal year -- a policy unquestioned for years.

        Anyhow...
        Per adjusted admission, the figures reveal what Commissioners approved five years ago ... compared to the District's current numbers. 
                   North Broward Hospital District
                     Commission approved budgets
                      (All $ per adjusted admission) 

Fiscal Year            2011         2015*          2016*
Gross Charges
Budget                          $32,098      $30,497       $33,619
Actual    
                      $30,917      $33,090      $33,384
Deductions
Budget                         ($25,007)   ($23,087)    ($24,461)
Actual                          ($24,010)     ($25,201)    ($25,800)
Bad Debt
Budget                        ($3,168)       ($3,371)       ($3,223)

Actual                         ($3,079)       ($3,366)       ($3,742)
Charity Care
Budget                        ($2,847)       ($1,066)      ($1,288)
Actual                         ($2,863        ($1,411)        ($1,355)
3rd Party/Other

Budget                        ($18,992)     ($18.649)   ($24,461)
Actual                
        ($18,066)     ($20,425)   ($20,732)
Total Reimbursed

Budget                         $7,091         $7,410         $7,745 
Actual                          $6,908         $7,889         $7,585
Total
Revenue

Budget                         $9,392         $9,577         $10,112
Actual                          
$9,878          $9,168         $9,528         

Total Expenses
Budget                         ($9,760)     ($9,364)     ($10,076)
Actual                          ($8,110)      ($8,668)     ($10,331)  

Surplus (Loss)
Budget                          $310               $213             $36
Actual                           $796             $500          ($803)

          The question, of course:

          What happened?
          Which I asked.
          To which District Commissioners responded with stone-faced silence when I (as a District taxpayer) posed the question during a public meeting on February 24, 2016.
           Oh yes.
           I was met with the same Sound of Silence when I asked the Commissioners to whom they are accountable.
           Which, as an alleged governmental agency by the people, for the people and of the people is bullshit.

                      The Past as Prologue  
 
          Students of History 101 may recall a tired cliche offered by their instructor during an early session:
           "It's difficult to know where you're going if you don't know where you've been."
              Which is the raison d'etre for the following:
                         North Broward Hospital District

                      Commission approved budgets
                      (All $ per adjusted admission)
                    (All $ adjusted for 21% inflation)

Total System               2005          2015            +-        
Adjusted
   Admissions                      99,665           119,311         19.7%
Surplus (Loss)
Per adj. admit
Budget                                   $345              $213            (38.3%)
Actual                                    $73                 $500            584.9%  

District Hospitals
Adjusted 

   Admissions                      89,264            107,218         20.1%
Surplus (Loss)
Per adj. admit
Budget                                  $805                $461            (42.7%)

Actual                                   $1,052              $878           (16.5%)
Non Hospital
  Programs
Adjusted
  Admissions                      10,401               12,093          16.3%
Surplus (Loss)

Per adj. admit.                  
Budget                                ($3,634)           ($1,922)         47.1%)
Actual                                 ($2,072)           ($1,810)         12.6% 

              Now...
            Theory is, the seven politically-appointed District Commissioners are able to understand the budgetary complexities and details where the countless fiduciary devils of accountability lie hidden.
             For example...

             On page 28 of the current 359-page District Budget for FY 2015-16, we find:
             The District has combined Cash and Investments totaling for $730,227,000.
             However, turning back to page 25, we discover the this $730,227,000 in Cash and Investements generated $12,796,473 in income.
              Which equals a "return" of roughly 1.7% on the District's $730 million dollars.
              Which might raise a few fiduciary eyebrows for some folk. 

              As a relevant aside...
              Most hospital systems like Broward Health depend on accounting devices like adjusted patient days and adjusted admissions to serve as baselines needed to track a jungle of revenue sources versus corresponding expenditures.
               For example, wading through the countless grey numerical columns in the District's current 359-page Budget, we find: 
                       North Broward Hospital District                 
                         Assets              Earnings       Investment
           Cash & Investments  Gain (Loss)    Mgmt. Fee

FY 2013        $626,815,000           $41,508,009      $1,398,699 
FY 2014       $673,611,000             $69,506,728     $2,203,906
FY 2015       $589,852,000            $12,796,475      $3,154,332

FY 2016       $484,128,000            $5,998,789*      $3,265,798*
                                                                          *projected
                 
What happened?
               Fair question.
               Not that any of the District Commissioners are willing to ask it -- let alone look for an answer.
               Anyhow..

               Speaking of that which few care to ponder regarding one of the nation's largest public health care systems, we have this fiduciary Rabbit Hole:
                        Broward County Hospitals
                     "Bottom Line" Surplus Revenue
                                     2008                2014                        
Broward Health
Broward Medical             $40,510,479        $14,309,647
Coral Springs                   $6,316,270            $7,652,077 
Imperial Point                 $9,491,128            $1,725,489
North Broward                $22,736,076         $7,807,543
Total                           $79,053,953     $31,494,758  (60%)
Memorial Healthcare

Memorial Miramar         $22,457,112         $39,158,503
Memorial Pembroke     ($625,310)          ($6,509,248)
Memorial Regional         $2,928,759          $16,563,035        
Memorial West                $30,408,322       $91,822,486
Total                            $55,168,883    $141,034,776  156%

Private Hospitals
Cleveland Clinic              $21,528,490         $80,421,706
Florida Medical              ($5,901,160)         $4,095,802

Holy Cross                       ($25,063,899)      $18,692,140
Northwest                        ($2,337,650)         $13,555,279
Plantation                        ($10,660,816)       $11,090,935
University                          $1,499,489           $7,605,123       

Westside                            $13,840,999         $29,089,726
Total                           ($7,094,547)    $164,550,711  242%              

Oh Really?!?

     With an annual budget of more than $1.2 billion and nearly 8,000 employees, the tax-funded North Broward Hospital District (dba Broward Health) is governed by a seven-member board of Commissioners  appointed by Florida Governor Rick Scott.
    The Commissioner's qualifications to govern the nation''s ninth largest public health care system?

    Active membership in Scott's Republican party.
    Further, note the unique CVs for two of Scott's latest appointees to Broward Health's  governing Board:

   



Sheela VanHoose, Governor Scott's former appointment secretary, current lobbyist for the Fort Lauderdale-based Charter Schools USA.



Christopher T. Ure, financial adviser Usb Financial Services, manager Dania-based Efficient Frontier Equine Ventures,  Efficient Frontier Consultancy, Frontier Cosmeticals, BioesqueCosmeticals    
      

Jumping Ship

Fleeing Rat
Fleeing 
Broward Health
Lobbyist