Saturday, March 5, 2016

Another something rotten?

             About sovereign immunity?
    For more than a decade, Phoenix -- a Boca-based, for-profit company -- has enjoyed an exclusive, no bid contract to operate the North Broward Hospital District's four Emergency Rooms.
     Phoenix is owned by Dr. Steven Scott, a long-time supporter of Florida Governor Rick Scott.
     Small  wonder -  for decades -  the District has served as a shameless Petri Dish for sweetheart contracts and backroom politics.
      This have led  to several current investigations.
      Including one by the US Department of Justice.

      And another by Governor Scott's Auditor General's Office.
      Obvious question, will anyone look into Dr. Scott's multi-million dollar no bid District ER contracts? 
      Fair question.
      Especially since the District has spent  more than $160 million on Dr. Scott's four Broward Health ERs during the past five years.
       And double-especially since the four ERs operated by Dr. Scott are "tort proof"  - thanks to their unique sovereign immunity status as for-profit portions of the District's non-profit, tax-supported status.
        Bottom line?
  Average Charge ER Visit - Level 4*
            Broward Tax Supported Hospitals                
Broward Medical - $722   Memorial Miramar - $640
Coral Springs - $838        Memorial Pembroke - $640
Imperial Point - $839        Memorial Regional - $639

North Broward - $858       Memorial West - $637
             *Type A - Life threatening condition     
     PS - Might any of this be linked to the recent suicide death of a Broward Health CEO and former Phoenix ER executive? 
              

Friday, March 4, 2016

"Healthy" Trends?

               Broward Hospital Trends
                                2008                       2014              +-
Licensed Beds          5,521                      5,642            2%
Avg. Patient Census  3,049                     2,971           (3%)
Occupancy Rate       55.2%
                     52.6%
Adjusted admissions 349,192                  390,128        12%
Surplus                     $127,128,289         $334,009,411
   per adj admission   $364                      $856             135%
Emergency Rooms
Visits                         506,647
                  665,284        35%
Surplus Profit
 per visit                    $2,704                    $4,111          52%

Thursday, March 3, 2016

$37.4 million question


Is this worth dying for?
Gov. Scott doesn't want you to know!
Stay tuned!


The Steve and Rick Show

Forget John Galt!
Who is Dr. Steven Scott?
It's a name Gov. Rick Scott* 
doesn't want you to know
*no relation other than  fiduciary


Where to, lady?


         Jane just had a heart attack while shopping at the Broward Mall.
          Now the nice paramedic is asking Jane which hospital Emergency Room she would like to visit for life-saving care.
          "America has the finest free market health care system in the world," the paramedic tells Jane. "And part of the beauty is people with  serious cardiac issues like you have a free choice regarding the emergency care vendor."

          "Gosh," Jane gasps between breaths from her oxygen mask, "is this a great couuntry, or what?"
          "No, Mam," the paramedic laughs. "None of that socialized-commie health care for us!"   

          Naturally, like most wise health care consumers, Jane is looking for the best bang for her heart attack buck.
          Which is how and why Florida's Agency for Health Care Administration operates an easy to access internet site with all the information any  penny-wise heart attack victim will need.
     
                Congestive Heart Failure
                                 Average Charge  
             Public                       2007           2014 
             Broward Health         $79,413      $83,645.                                     Coral Springs            $48,689      $39,753
             Imperial Point            $38,543      $31,657
             North Broward           $47,777      $48,920
             Memorial Miramar      $41,055      $72,911
             Memorial Pembroke   $49,309      $73,848
             Memorial Regional     $62,971      $109,703
             Memorial South         $46,512       $51,559
             Memorial West           $44,279      $87,678             

             Private
             Cleveland Clinic         $47,071      $52,442
             Florida Medical          $85,872      $103,908
             Holy Cross                 $75,438      $65,475

             Northwest                  $52,125      $105,247
             Plantation                  $61,733      $120,293
             University                   $46,970      $73,869
             Westside                    $68,667      $101,638

             
                  

Wednesday, March 2, 2016

More Anomalies...

   Data and anecdotal material suggest more health care consumers are relying on Emergency Rooms versus private physicians for their health care needs.
   Further, a comparison of Broward's two tax suppported hospital systems suggests the North Broward Hospital District is using tax dollars to compensate for its low patient charges and reimbursement levels -- and thus engaging in unfair competition with private hospitals in its market area.
   Which is good news for a savvy health care consumer.
   But maybe bad news for consumers forced to seek care from hospitals other than those operated by Broward Health. 

Broward Health                          2008             2014
  tax suppported
Broward Medical
Adjusted Admissions               41,332       44,077
Charge per Adj. Admission    $39,204      $39,900 
ER Visits                                 75,499        91,025
Charge per ER Visit               $2,468       $2,982
Coral Springs
Adjusted Admissions               21,397        25,309
Charge per Adj. Admission     $26,129      $25,258            
ER Visits                                 36,153        53,395
Charge per ER Visit               $3,296        $3,583
Imperial Point
Adjusted Admissions                14,690       17,954
Charge per Adj. Admission      $24,023     $23,635
ER Visits                                  18,391        25,797
Charge per ER Visit                $2,281       $2,979
North Broward 
Adjusted Admissions                 21,575       21,000
Charge per Adj. Admission      $36,216      $45,525
ER Visits                                    38,848       43,451
Charge per ER Visit                  $2,488        $3,521

Memorial Healthcare                 2008                2014
tax supported                                                                                    
Memorial Miramar
Adjusted Admissions                18,121          18,509
Charge per Adj. Admission      $23,541        $41,502            

ER Visits                                   23,573          27,985
Charge per ER Visit                 $2,784          $4,815  

Memorial Pembroke
Adjusted Admissions                 14,636          12,560
Charge per Adj. Admission       $31,346        $55,842          

ER Visits                                    23,105          26,365
Charge per ER Visit                  $2,304          $5,237  
Memorial Regional
Adjusted Admissions                 66,415           61,838

Charge per Adj. Admission      $35,766         $63,507       
ER Visits                                   85,102           102,385
Charge per ER Visit                 $2,069           $3,914   
Memorial West
Adjusted Admissions                 40,207           40,505
Charge per Adj. Admission      $28,453         $54,973          
ER Visits                                   39,850           50,162
Charge per ER Visit                 $2,344           $4,969   

Private Hospitals                            2008                  
2014
Cleveland Clinic 
non profit
 Adjusted Admissions                  18,048         19,282
Charge per Adj. Admission         $33,540      $51,317           

ER Visits                                     15,445          21,059
Charge per ER Visit                   $2,203        $5,550        
Holy Cross non profit
Adjusted Admissions                   29,696         30,124
Charge per Adj. Admission         $49,797      $47,079        
ER Visits                                      26,710         39,168
Charge per ER Visit                    $2,520         $4,104       
Northwest   for profit
Adjusted Admissions                   17,950          21,095
Charge per Adj. Admission         $39,110       $69,049         
ER Visits                                      23,381         35,819
Charge per ER Visit                    $3,301         $6,864   
Plantation   for profit
Adjusted Admissions                   13,387           41,866*
Charge per Adj. Admission         $41,623         $63,389   
ER Visits                                      30,582          51,882*
Charge per ER Visit                     $3,334          $5,827 
University   for profit
Adjusted Admissions                    14,129          17,435
Charge per Adj. Admission          $32,251       $49,166      
ER Visits                                       17,594         26,456
Charge per ER Visit                     $4,056         $7,370
Westside   for profit
Adjusted Admissions                    16,906         18,744
Charge per Adj. Admission          $45,907       $71,005        
ER Visits                                       24,679         32,479
Charge per ER Visit                     $3,037         $7,370 
     
*Plantation data combined with Mercy in Miami-Dade County  Adjusted Admission - Standard Health Care industry baseline based on a formula that enables the comparison of one hospital or hospital group to another.       

Tuesday, March 1, 2016

"A sharp decline"...?

    Moody's Investor Service, Inc. has downgraded the bonds issued by Broward Health, citing a "sharp decline" in financial performance, no clear plan for improvements, turnover in senior management and the presence of outside investigations.
     The rating of the North Broward Hospital Disrrict, the organization's legal name,was downgraded from A2 to Baa2, a change that Moody's said reflects deficit operations and "extremely thin cash flow" occurring "without a clear plan for regaining operational balance." 
                                South Florida Sun-Sentinel  -3/1/2016  
        North Broward Hospital District
                 Broward Health
      (All figures per adjusted admission)
Fiscal Year             2015         2016
                      (First Seven Months)
Gross Charges             $33,090        $33,385            0.9%
Deductions                   ($25,200)    ($25,800)      

Bad Debt                       ($3,366)      ($3,742)
   Charity Care            ($1,411)        ($1,355) 
   3rd Party,Other       ($20,423)    ($20,703)
Total Reimbursed        $8,529          $8,169            (4.2%)
Per $1 gross charge    23.8 cents    22.7 cents       (4.6%)
Other Op. Revenue      $424            $512              20.7%  
Net Operating Rev.     $8,952           $8,678            (3.1%)    
Non Operating Rev.    $1,313            $850              (35.3%)  
Total Revenue               $10,265        $9,528            (7.2%)
Operating Exp.           ($9,143)        ($9,709
)  
Non Op. Expenses       ($216)           ($207)
Total Expenses*             ($9,359)       ($9,916)            5.9% 
Surplus (Loss)*            $906         ($388)        (131%) ???
                                                    *Excluding Depreciation
            Source - Broward Health - 2/18/2016
              Where's the Grand Jury?