Thursday, March 10, 2016

Confession

      For most of my career as a journalist, I took shameless pleasure in the fear and status that came with my press card.
      Even when working for a rinky-dink small town Ohio daily, I enjoyed a hearing someone mutter:
      "Better watch out for deGroot! He's with the Record-Courier."
       There was also the ego-feeding knowledge that most folks would return my phone calls promptly -- if they knew I was with the press.
      And finally...
      Nearly always, my healthcare blog includes a cruel and unspoken caveat:
      "When it comes to the nation's healthcare industry, most Americans are as dumb as a box of rocks and  as helpless as a one-legged man in an ass-kicking contest."
       Mea culpa?
       Mine is the venal sin of knowing when others don't.
       And flaunting it.
       Like this... 
                              Diagnostic Service Group
                              Congestive Heart Failure
                                  Broward     Memorial
                                  Medical       Regional        
        White                  656              1,337

          Avg. Charge            $89,925         $103,100
         Black                   869             588
          Avg. Charge             $76,877         $114,090
          Hispanic             95                313
          Avg. Charge             $105,530      $111,412
          Avg. All               1,641           2,137

          Avg. Charge             $83,645        $109,703
                               

Wednesday, March 9, 2016

Word for the day

Anomaly - Something unusual, or unexpected*
                                                      Merriam-Webster Dictionary
                                                  
                              Example
                                                                           
                           North Broward Hospital District  
          Governing Board of Commissioners

                         Scheduled Meetings
                             March 2015  - 3
                             March 2016  - 8


                                   Why?

Tuesday, March 8, 2016

Exploring the healthcare jungle - Part #1

     As a retired journalist, I've spent more than a decade wandering the surreal jungle created by the nations alleged "free market"  healthcare system.
     Cutting, as they say, to the  chase:
     Here in Florida, hospitals have been able to increase their profits for the same reason male dogs can lick their balls.
       Which is: Because they can.
        How so?
        Ironically, in an early attempt to slow the skyrocketing cost of hospital care, the Florida legislature created the Florida Hospital Cost Containment Board some four decades ago.
        Then, after several years, the the "Cost Containment" agency was renamed the Florida Agency for Health Care Administration (AHCA).
        But as AHCA, the agency's primary task remained the same as its predecessor: To track hospital costs (and profits) in Florida.

        That said, it seems AHCA has been successful in keeping hospital patient care charges under control - when adjusted for inflation.
         However, at the same time,hospitals have managed to reduce their patient care costs - they've failed to pass on the benefits of their efforts to the health patient consumer.
        Especially when it comes to the hospital industry's  increase in bottom line profits. 
                                      Florida Hospitals
                                 Trends - Costs v Profits
                          Per Adjusted Admission

      All Hospitals       1990          2000       2013
       Charges                $5,464       $6,916    $10,061
       
In 2013 dollars        $10,244         $9,328      $10,061

       Cost                       $5,286       $6,674    $9,362
        In 2013 dollars          $9,927           $9,009      $9,362
       Profit                     $178            $242       $699
       
In 2013 dollars         $317               $317           $699

       Margin                  3.3%            3.6%       7.5%      
          Today, AHCA has launched yet another website -- this time at www.floridahealthfinder.gov.
          Where once again, we find Florida hospital costs are more Persian market than free market.
          Only time, AHCA's data covers selected diseases.
          For example, consider the insanity of various Chargemasters at work in a comparison of hospital charges between 2007  and 2014  .                             
                                    Chronic Disease
                          "Congestive Heart Failure"
                                  Broward Hospitals
                                     Average Charge
                                             2007           2014
    Broward Health
     Broward Medical      $79,240     $83,645 
    Adjusted for inflation        $106,974       $83,645
    Coral Springs               $52,494     $39,753

    Adjusted for inflation        $70,867         $39,753
    Imperial Point              $37,682     $31,657
    Adjusted for inflation          $50,871         $31,657
    North Broward             $39,242    $48,920   
    Adjusted for inflation          $52,977         $48,920  
   
Memorial Healthcare

    Memorial Miramar     $48,461     $72,911
    Adjusted for inflation          $65,422       $72,911
    Memorial Pembroke    $49,923    $73,848    

     Adjusted for inflation           $67,396        $73,848 
    Memorial Regional       $64,095   $109,703
     Adjusted for inflation          $86,598       $109,703
     Memorial South            $43,313    $51,556
     
Adjusted for inflation           $58,473       $58,473

     Memorial West              $48,374   $87,678
     Adjusted for inflation          $65,305        $87,678
     Private Hospitals

     Cleveland Clinic            $43,648    $52,442
     Adjusted for inflation          $58,925        $52,442
     Florida Medical           $90,418     $103,908
     
Adjusted for inflation          $122,064      $103,908
     Holy Cross                     $70,460     $65,475 

     Adjusted for inflation         $95,121          $65,475
     Northwest                     $58,882      $105,247
     Adjusted for inflation         $79,491           $105,247
      Plantation                     $86,009     $120,293

     Adjusted for inflation         $116,112          $120,293
     University                      $51,416      $73,869
     
Adjusted for inflation          $69,412         $73,869

     Westside                         $83,095     $101,638
.    
Adjusted for inflation          $112,178        $101,638

Monday, March 7, 2016

Data as Metaphor

   Journalistic sins of omission or commission.
   Do you know the difference?
   Read the South Florida Sun-Sentinel*
    Because journalistic sins of this sort matter - given Governor Rick Scott's current policies impacting Florida hospitals.                   
   *Not that you'll find any of the startling data below in South Florida's "most valued information provider."
   

                            Broward County 
               Average Daily Hospital Census
                        Twenty Year Trend
                                            1995             2014
Broward Medical             369              409

Uninsured                                    84                    52
Medicare                                      108                  120 

Medicaid                                      105                  162 
Other Insured                              72                    75

Surplus (Loss)
per adjusted admission         ($311)             $325
Coral Springs                    102               138  
Uninsured                                   13                      16

Medicare                                      31                      49
Medicaid                                      10                      18
Other Insured                            48                      55

Surplus (Loss)                            
per adjusted admission          $21                    $302
Imperial Point                 101                 99

Uninsured                                18                         13
Medicare                                     48                     48
Medicaid                                     6                        18
Other Insured                            29.                     20
Surplus (Loss)

per adjusted admission        ($113)                 $96
North Broward                193               213
Uninsured                                  32                       32                     
Medicare                                    101                      105
Medicaid                                     23                       55
Other Insured                           37                         21

Surplus (Loss)
per adjusted admission         $164                    $372


Memorial Miramar        Not Open      85    
Uninsured                                                              7
Medicare                                                                27
Medicaid                                                                19 
Other Insured                                                       32
Surplus (Loss)

per Adjusted Admission                                    $2,116
Memorial Pembroke     Private          69 
Uninsured                                                             10

Medicare                                                               38
Medicaid                                                               11

Other Insured                                                      10
Surplus (Loss)
 per Adjusted Admission                                  ($518)      
Memorial Regional     436                 542 

Uninsured                               110                       62 
Medicare                                  157                      185
Medicaid                                  69                        174
Other Insured                        100                      121

Surplus (Loss)
per Adjusted Admission       $212                  $268
Memorial West              74                   258         
Uninsured                               7                            20
Medicare                                  32                         111
Medicaid                                  4                           49
Other Insured                          31                         78 

Surplus (Loss)
per Adjusted Admission     $423                   $2,267

Cleveland Clinic            67                  127
Uninsured                               3                           4  
Medicare                                 45                         69
Medicaid                                  2                           2
Other Insured.                        17                        52

Surplus (Loss)
per Admission                      $422                   $4,171

Holy Cross                     259                 221
Uninsured                              13                         9
Medicare                                 178                      135
Medicaid                                 17                        22
Other Insured                        51                        55
Surplus (Loss)
per Adjusted Admission     $779                  $620

Northwest                      74                   153
Uninsured                               2                          11          

Medicare                                 52                        86
Medicaid                                 3                           26
Other Insured                        17                         30
Surplus (Loss)

per Adjusted Admission    $415                    $690
Pembroke - Private     35                     Public
Uninsured                              1  

Medicare                                22
Medicaid                                2
Other Insured                       10

Surplues (Loss)
per Adjusted Admission     ($89)  
Plantation                      126                    NA           

Uninsured                               2 
Medicare                                 31
Medicaid                                 32
Other Insured                        61

Surplus (Loss)
per Adjusted Admission     $210
University                      128                    146 

Uninsured                              3                              16 
Medicare                                 81                            86
Medicaid                                 4                              19
Other Insured                       40                            25

Surplus (Loss)
per Adjusted Admission    $1,346                   $436

Westside                         111                    170 
Uninsured                               5                             9
Medicare                                 41                            113
Medicaid                                 4                              14
Other Insured                        61                           34

Surplus (Loss)
per Adjusted Admission    $561                      $1,552

Angels on pins

    Debating the number of angels able to occupy the head of a pin serves as one of the darkest moments of intellectual curiosity during the Dark Ages.
    However...
    Centuries later, Florida spends millions of tax dollars tracking the cost of hospital care in the Sunshine State.
     Which, for the average "health care consumer" in the Sunshine is almost as irrelevant as counting angels on pinheads.
      As if, in the midst of a heart attack, Uncle Harry insists the EMS team rush him to the hospital with the least expensive Emergency Room.

      But...
      For those unique few of you looking for the best deal on a heart attack as opposed to Doreen's Deal on a bargain burger according to the Sun-Sentinel...
                   Congestive Heart Failure                                         Agency for Health Care Administration
                               Broward County
                               Average Charge   
           
                                2008                 2014               % + 
Broward Medical     $79,240            $83,464          5.3%
Coral Springs           $52,494            $39,753         (24.3%)
Imperial Point           $37,682            $31,657         (15.9%)
North Broward         $39,242            $48,920           24.6%
           
Memorial Miramar    $48,461            $72,911           50.4%
Memorial Pembroke $49,923            $73,848           47.9%
Memorial Regional    $45,085            $75,090           56.1%
Memorial West         $48,374            $87,678           81.2%
   
Cleveland Clinic         $43,648           $52,442           20.1%
Florida Medical          $90,418            $103,908         47.5%
Holy Cross                 $70,460            $65,475          (7.4%)
Northwest                   $58,882           $105,247         78.7%
Plantation                   $86,009           $120,293         39.9%
University                   $51,416           $73,869           43.7%
Westside                    $83,095           $101,638         22.3%  
           

Mysterious Chargemasters

    Each hospital creates and maintains a data-based Chargemaster to track its costs and charges.
   For example, based on its data-driven Chargemaster. executives at Miami-Dade's public Jackson Memorial Hospital know the average charge for an outpatient  Lower GI Endoscopy is $2,475 versus an average cost of $790.
    Data of this sort, of course, is essential in Jackson Memorial's negotiations with health insurance providers to establish levels of reimbursement for various types of patient care.
    However, a comparison of charges set by the
Chargemaster at Hospital A versus those at Hospital B  seem more like those of haggle-driven a Persian market.
    For example:
                              Outpatient Procedure
                            South Florida Hospitals

                 Diagnostic Cardiac Catheterization
                               APC Number 0080
                                            Charge            Cost

             Broward Medical      $8,708             $555
             Cleveland Clinic       $10,592           $1,263
             Holy Cross               $22,699           $2,604
             Memorial Regional   $9,312             $1,462
             Northwest                $18,426           $1,271
             Plantation General   $8,708             $555 

             Westside                  $24,104           $909
             Baptist of Miami       $22,483            $3,872
             Jackson                   $18,000            $2,880

             Kendall Regional     $22,423            $1,419
             North Shore             $29,739            $2,549
             Palm Springs           $12,799            $843
             South Miami             $20,156            $1,993

             Bethesda                 $11,532            $903
             Delray                      $26,765            $2,280

             Good Samaritan       $10,652            $1,217
             JFK Medical             $43,597            $1,588

"How much for a Cath?"