Tuesday, March 8, 2016

Exploring the healthcare jungle - Part #1

     As a retired journalist, I've spent more than a decade wandering the surreal jungle created by the nations alleged "free market"  healthcare system.
     Cutting, as they say, to the  chase:
     Here in Florida, hospitals have been able to increase their profits for the same reason male dogs can lick their balls.
       Which is: Because they can.
        How so?
        Ironically, in an early attempt to slow the skyrocketing cost of hospital care, the Florida legislature created the Florida Hospital Cost Containment Board some four decades ago.
        Then, after several years, the the "Cost Containment" agency was renamed the Florida Agency for Health Care Administration (AHCA).
        But as AHCA, the agency's primary task remained the same as its predecessor: To track hospital costs (and profits) in Florida.

        That said, it seems AHCA has been successful in keeping hospital patient care charges under control - when adjusted for inflation.
         However, at the same time,hospitals have managed to reduce their patient care costs - they've failed to pass on the benefits of their efforts to the health patient consumer.
        Especially when it comes to the hospital industry's  increase in bottom line profits. 
                                      Florida Hospitals
                                 Trends - Costs v Profits
                          Per Adjusted Admission

      All Hospitals       1990          2000       2013
       Charges                $5,464       $6,916    $10,061
       
In 2013 dollars        $10,244         $9,328      $10,061

       Cost                       $5,286       $6,674    $9,362
        In 2013 dollars          $9,927           $9,009      $9,362
       Profit                     $178            $242       $699
       
In 2013 dollars         $317               $317           $699

       Margin                  3.3%            3.6%       7.5%      
          Today, AHCA has launched yet another website -- this time at www.floridahealthfinder.gov.
          Where once again, we find Florida hospital costs are more Persian market than free market.
          Only time, AHCA's data covers selected diseases.
          For example, consider the insanity of various Chargemasters at work in a comparison of hospital charges between 2007  and 2014  .                             
                                    Chronic Disease
                          "Congestive Heart Failure"
                                  Broward Hospitals
                                     Average Charge
                                             2007           2014
    Broward Health
     Broward Medical      $79,240     $83,645 
    Adjusted for inflation        $106,974       $83,645
    Coral Springs               $52,494     $39,753

    Adjusted for inflation        $70,867         $39,753
    Imperial Point              $37,682     $31,657
    Adjusted for inflation          $50,871         $31,657
    North Broward             $39,242    $48,920   
    Adjusted for inflation          $52,977         $48,920  
   
Memorial Healthcare

    Memorial Miramar     $48,461     $72,911
    Adjusted for inflation          $65,422       $72,911
    Memorial Pembroke    $49,923    $73,848    

     Adjusted for inflation           $67,396        $73,848 
    Memorial Regional       $64,095   $109,703
     Adjusted for inflation          $86,598       $109,703
     Memorial South            $43,313    $51,556
     
Adjusted for inflation           $58,473       $58,473

     Memorial West              $48,374   $87,678
     Adjusted for inflation          $65,305        $87,678
     Private Hospitals

     Cleveland Clinic            $43,648    $52,442
     Adjusted for inflation          $58,925        $52,442
     Florida Medical           $90,418     $103,908
     
Adjusted for inflation          $122,064      $103,908
     Holy Cross                     $70,460     $65,475 

     Adjusted for inflation         $95,121          $65,475
     Northwest                     $58,882      $105,247
     Adjusted for inflation         $79,491           $105,247
      Plantation                     $86,009     $120,293

     Adjusted for inflation         $116,112          $120,293
     University                      $51,416      $73,869
     
Adjusted for inflation          $69,412         $73,869

     Westside                         $83,095     $101,638
.    
Adjusted for inflation          $112,178        $101,638

No comments:

Post a Comment